Archive

Posts Tagged ‘Israel’

Is following a valid argument?

January 25, 2009 2 comments

Whatever Israel does is wrong regardless of the fact that so many other countries do worse.

When I raised this concern in a recent debate, my opponent accused me of changing the subject. He said we are talking about Israel now, not Chechnya or Darfur. This reminded me of a famous exchange between Harvard’s former president, Abbott Lawrence Lowell, and the great American judge Leonard Hand. Lowell announced that he wanted to reduce the number of Jews at Harvard, because, “Jews cheat.” Judge Hand replied that “Christians also cheat.” Lowell responded, “You’re changing the subject. We are talking about Jews.”

-Alan Dershowitz on JPOST

“Jews cheat” is a statistical claim and if you want to make a policy based on that then you have to show specifically  that  “Non-jews don’t cheat” so often. This is the meaning of the reply of the judge, “Christians also cheat”.  In the case of war crime of Israel, no one is saying that “All jewish states does war crimes” more often then others. But, they are pointing at specific incidents of crimes.

If you respond to an accusation, which is not statistical but an specific crime,  by saying that others also have done it then you are certainly changing the subject.

Advertisements

Will there be a ‘war crime’ tribunal?

January 22, 2009 Leave a comment

Yesterday, Ban ki moon, UN head, called for war crime investigation against Israel for attacking UN compound in Gaza. Other human rights watch groups are calling for wider investigation. I don’t know how UN functions. I guess there would be a vote in security council or in general assembly for creation of investigation. Lets see how US reacts to this proposition.

This will be a litmus test for Obama!

(If you have not been following horror’s of Gaza then you should!)

Categories: Politics Tags: , , , , ,